Why networking opens doors, but presence determines what happens when you walk through them.
The Hidden Psychology of Business
By Elle Lorenzoni
We spend years learning to become qualified. We acquire knowledge, demonstrate competence, work diligently and distinguish ourselves through achievement. Yet one of the most consequential mechanisms of professional advancement is rarely taught with comparable seriousness: how opportunity travels between people.
We call it networking, a word that has reduced an extraordinary social mechanism to business cards, receptions and LinkedIn connections. What it actually describes is how people come to know, remember, trust and, ultimately, advocate for one another. At the centre of that process is presence.
The education we never received
Consider how many opportunities begin without an advertisement, application or formal selection process. Someone mentions a name. A colleague makes an introduction. A decision-maker asks someone they trust for a recommendation. The opportunity may eventually become public, but its earliest circulation is often private.
Mark Granovetter’s study The Strength of Weak Ties showed that acquaintances, more than close friends, connect otherwise separate social circles and carry information beyond our immediate world. Ronald Burt later studied managers at an American electronics firm. He found that those whose networks spanned structural holes, the gaps between disconnected groups, had their ideas rated more valuable, earned more and were promoted more often.
Yet we rarely explain this architecture of opportunity to young professionals. We encourage them to become exceptional and assume exceptionalism will eventually be discovered. The promise is appealing, but it leaves out how discovery actually happens.
Being present is not having presence
Networking provides the encounter. Presence influences what happens within it. There is a difference between occupying space and making an impression that survives your departure.
Some people mistake volume for presence. They dominate conversations, announce their accomplishments and confuse attention with authority. Others assume that attending enough events will eventually produce meaningful relationships. Neither approach reliably creates influence.
Presence comes from the Latin praeesse, which meant to be before or at hand, and also to preside over others. The link between being present and holding authority is an old one.
Presence is not simply confidence, charisma or physical appearance. It can emerge through the precision of a question, the quality of one’s listening, composure, or the ability to contribute something another person had not previously considered.
Susan Fiske, Amy Cuddy and Peter Glick have shown that we judge others along two universal dimensions, warmth and competence, with warmth typically judged first and weighted heavily. Competence displayed without warmth can provoke wariness. Presence therefore carries both an opportunity and a danger: it can help communicate genuine competence, but it can also disguise its absence.
The psychology of being remembered
Robert Zajonc’s research on the mere-exposure effect established that repeated exposure tends to improve attitudes toward the familiar. Familiarity does not guarantee trust, but it makes someone more recognisable and approachable.
But there is another psychological obstacle. Tiziana Casciaro, Francesca Gino and Maryam Kouchaki found that networking deliberately for professional advantage can leave people feeling morally tainted. In one experiment, participants who recalled such networking rated cleansing products as more desirable. People with greater power felt less of this discomfort and networked more freely.
As a result, the people who stand to gain most from building connections are often the most likely to find it distasteful. We have failed to teach the distinction between exploiting relationships and cultivating them.
Why the familiar outrank the exceptional
Why will a decision-maker so often choose an adequate candidate they know over a superior one they do not?
Trust is part of the answer. Roger Mayer, James Davis and David Schoorman defined trust as a willingness to be vulnerable to another person, based on perceptions of their ability, benevolence and integrity. A CV can show ability. Benevolence and integrity usually have to be learned through experience of the person.
Liking also plays a role. Analysing more than 10,000 work relationships, Tiziana Casciaro and Miguel Sousa Lobo found that people would rather work with a likeable colleague of modest competence than a capable one they disliked.
Familiarity also protects the person making the decision. When a known candidate disappoints, there is a history to point to. When an unknown candidate fails, people tend to question the judgment of whoever chose them.
The unknown candidate asks the decision-maker to absorb uncertainty and reputational risk. Presence is how a stranger starts to reduce that burden. In conversation, benevolence and integrity begin to show in how someone listens, what they ask and how they carry themselves. Each encounter makes a person a little less unknown.
Who is granted presence?
Not everyone enters a professional room on equal terms. Some inherit networks through family, education, class and institutional affiliation; their introductions arrive with implied credibility. Others must establish that credibility while learning the unwritten rules of access.
Herminia Ibarra’s research on professional networks in an advertising firm documented differences in men’s and women’s network structures and the benefits they derived from them. Later, Ibarra, with Nancy Carter and Christine Silva, found that women were often mentored but less often sponsored by senior leaders willing to use their own influence to secure a promotion. Women received plenty of advice and comparatively little advocacy.
Networking cannot eliminate structural inequality. Pretending otherwise merely converts unequal access into an accusation of inadequate personal effort. Nevertheless, understanding these mechanisms provides greater agency within imperfect systems.
In 1989, a young Xerox engineer named Ursula Burns stood up at a company meeting and challenged an executive vice president, Wayland Hicks, over what she saw as an unprincipled answer about diversity. She expected to be fired, as she later recalled. Instead, Hicks kept talking with her and, the following year, made her his executive assistant, the role that brought her into the C-suite. Burns would later become Xerox’s chief executive.
The difference between contacts and capital
A contact is someone whose details you possess. A relationship is something developed through meaningful exchange. The objective in any room is to leave having established a reason for a conversation to continue. That reason might be an intelligent question, a shared interest, a useful introduction or an unexpected perspective.
Relationships built exclusively around extraction rarely inspire enduring trust. The most valuable professional networks allow knowledge, credibility and opportunity to move in more than one direction.
The word currency comes from the Latin currere, to run. Money earns the name because it circulates. Presence works in a similar way when other people carry it, mentioning your name and your work in rooms you never entered.
Building presence
Presence can be developed. Four habits help.
Ask follow-up questions. Karen Huang and colleagues at Harvard found that people who asked more questions, particularly follow-up questions, were better liked by their conversation partners. A follow-up shows that you were listening, which is one of the clearest ways warmth comes across.
Make your value easy to describe. If someone cannot explain what you do in a sentence, they are unlikely to pass your name along. Be clear and specific about your work so that others can describe it accurately.
Reconnect before you need something. Daniel Levin, Jorge Walter and Keith Murnighan found that executives who revived dormant ties often received advice that was more novel than, and as valuable as, advice from their current contacts. Reaching out to someone you have not spoken to in years is usually worth the brief awkwardness.
Make yourself easy to recommend. Anyone who recommends you puts some of their own reputation at stake. Deliver visible results, keep small promises and give the people who support you concrete evidence they can point to.
What remains when you leave
The real test of presence comes after the encounter. When an opportunity emerges, does someone remember your name? Can they articulate what you contribute? Would they introduce you, recommend you or invite you into a consequential conversation?
Presence without substance may attract attention. Substance without sufficient exposure may remain undiscovered. Networking connects the two, but credibility determines whether that connection endures.
Qualifications matter. Competence matters. Hard work matters. But professional decisions are also shaped by networks of information, memory and trust.
Being known matters, but the deeper question is whether the people who know you understand your value well enough to act upon it.
Elle Lorenzoni is an entrepreneur, writer and commentator focused on gender, power and professional life.
She holds a BA in Rhetoric from the University of California, Berkeley, a Juris Doctor from Loyola University Chicago School of Law, and an LL.M. from the University of Fribourg in Switzerland. She began her career at the William Morris Agency in Los Angeles before developing ventures including Planning Pretty Picnics and The Spoken World, a platform for spoken word and diasporic storytelling.

